Weakest Homeowners Insurers

Strongest Auto Insurers	Strongest Business Insurers	Strongest Homeowners Insurers
Weakest Auto Insurers	Weakest Business Insurers	Weakest Homeowners Insurers

Company	State	Total Assets ($000)	Weiss Financial Strength Rating
Adirondack Ins Exch	NY	251,543	D
Agents Mutual Ins Co	AR	1,509	D
Alliance Mutual Ins Co	NC	9,898	D+
American Farmers & Ranchers Mutual	OK	85,973	D+
American Fellowship Mut Ins Co	MI	6,704	D
American Integrity Ins Co Of FL	FL	93,360	D
American Traditions Ins Co	FL	31,124	D+
Americas Ins Co	LA	10,829	D+
Argonaut-Midwest Ins Co	IL	43,502	D+
Argus Fire & Casualty Ins Co	FL	38,496	D
Arizona Home Ins Co	AZ	16,351	D
Associated Mutual Ins Co	NY	27,495	D+
Atlantic Mutual Ins Co	NY	205,447	E-
Axis Surplus Ins Co	IL	378,412	D
Battle Creek Mutual Ins Co	NE	4,746	E
California Mutual Ins Co	CA	13,163	D-
Canonsburg Mutual Fire Ins Co	PA	1,966	D
Capitol Preferred Ins Co	FL	35,039	D-
Casualty Corp Of America	OK	5,034	E+
Catawba Ins Co	SC	11,100	D
Centennial Ins Co	NY	74,859	E-
Central Co-Operative Ins Co	NY	10,374	D
Centre County Mutual Fire Ins Co	PA	4,565	D+
Cherry Valley Cooperative Ins Co	NY	1,354	D
Colonial Lloyds	TX	28,384	D
Community Mutual Ins Co	NY	4,113	D
Conemaugh Valley Mutual Ins Co	PA	4,679	D
Consolidated Lloyds	TX	2,527	D+
Constitutional Casualty Co	IL	17,768	E+
Crum & Forster Indemnity Co	DE	36,062	D+
Cypress Property & Casualty Ins Co	FL	102,262	D
Cypress Texas Lloyds	TX	46,515	D
Delaware Grange Mutual Fire Ins Co	DE	1,206	D
Delos Ins Co	DE	601,209	D+
Delta Lloyds Ins Co Of Houston	TX	9,616	D
Dongbu Ins Co Ltd	HI	36,131	D-
Edison Ins Co	FL	20,075	E+
Elizabethtown Ins Co	PA	6,709	D+
Farm Bureau New Horizons Ins Co MO	MO	7,895	D+
Farmers & Mech Mu I Asn Of Cecil Cty	MD	1,390	D+
Farmers & Mechanics Fire & Cas Ins	WV	4,481	D
Farmers Mutual F I C Of Branch Cty	MI	1,781	E
Farmers Mutual Ins Co	MI	2,819	D
Farmers Mutual Ins Co	WV	9,950	F
Farmers Mutual Ins Co Of Ellinwood	KS	4,620	D
Farmers Union Mutual Ins Co	AR	6,573	D
Farmington Mutual Ins Co	WI	6,304	D
Federated National Ins Co	FL	77,398	D-
Financial Casualty & Surety Inc	TX	21,145	D+
First Home Ins Co	FL	49,980	D
First Mutual Ins Co	NC	4,326	D
First Net Ins Co	GU	12,805	D-
First Protective Ins Co	FL	62,286	D-
Fremont Ins Co	MI	89,441	D+
Fulmont Mutual Ins Co	NY	5,381	D
Genesee Patrons Coop Ins	NY	6,812	D-
Geovera Ins Co	CA	98,155	D+
Global Liberty Ins Co Of NY	NY	40,291	D-
Golden Bear Ins Co	CA	97,563	D
Grain Dealers Mutual Ins Co	IN	45,673	D+
Grange Mutual Fire Ins Co	PA	2,978	D+
Great Lakes Mutual Ins Co	MI	4,986	D
Great Northwest Ins Co	IN	24,658	D
Gulfstream Prop & Cas Ins Co	FL	65,037	D+
Halifax Mutual Ins Co	NC	6,093	D+
Hannahstown Mutual Ins Co	PA	2,688	D
Hanover Fire & Casualty Ins Co	PA	3,269	D+
Homeowners Choice Prop & Cas Ins Co	FL	111,630	D
Homeowners Of America Ins Co	TX	13,332	D-
Homesite Ins Co Of Ca	CA	80,865	D+
Homesite Ins Co Of The Midwest	ND	167,225	D+
Homewise Preferred Ins Co	FL	90,735	D
Integrity Prop & Cas Ins Co	WI	13,761	D+
Interboro Mutual Indemnity Ins Co	NY	73,964	E
Juniata Mutual Ins Co	PA	7,128	D+
Kentucky National Ins Co	KY	7,594	D+
Leatherstocking Coop Ins Co	NY	13,504	D+
Lebanon Mutual Ins Co	PA	26,045	D
Lincoln General Ins Co	PA	706,433	E+
Lincoln Mutual Ins Co	NC	2,701	D
Little Black Mutual Ins Co	WI	4,866	D-
Lumbermens Mutual Cas Co	IL	1,124,027	E
Manitowoc Mutual Ins Co	WI	6,305	D
Members Ins Co	NC	6,114	E+
Mid-Continent Ins Co	PA	40,589	D
Middle Georgia Mutual Ins Co	GA	13,016	D+
Midrox Ins Co	NY	5,565	D+
Millers First Ins Co	IL	36,857	D+
Missouri Valley Mutual Ins Co	SD	5,593	D+
Montour Mutual Ins Co	PA	1,074	D
Mount Carroll Mutual Ins Co	IL	3,154	D
Mountain Valley Indemnity Co	NH	72,651	D
Mt Morris Mutual Ins Co	WI	18,674	D+
Mutual Ins Co Of Lehigh Cty	PA	3,955	D
Mutual Savings Fire Ins Co	AL	6,258	D
Nazareth Mutual Ins Co	PA	11,285	D+
North East Ins Co	ME	102,408	D
Northern Capital Ins Co	FL	65,238	E
Northwest Gf Mutual Ins Co	SD	10,855	D
Oklahoma Farm Bureau Mutual Ins Co	OK	299,095	D
Olympus Ins Co	FL	39,134	D
Omega Ins Co	FL	39,777	E+
Otsego County Patrons Co-Op F R Asn	NY	1,986	D
Pacific Indemnity Ins Co	GU	17,895	D+
Pacific Pioneer Insurance Co	CA	22,410	D+
Pacific Specialty Property & Cas Co	TX	3,363	E
Palisades Property & Casualty Ins	NJ	57,484	D
Patrons Mutual Fire Ins Co Of In PA	PA	2,624	D+
Peoples Trust Ins Co	FL	26,039	D-
Piedmont Mutual Ins Co	NC	3,002	D
Prime Ins Co	IL	43,794	D
Ranchers & Farmers Ins Co	TX	7,544	D+
Reamstown Mutual Ins Co	PA	5,890	D
Royal Palm Ins Co	FL	633,523	E+
Rutgers Casualty Ins Co	NJ	50,952	D+
Safe Harbor Ins Co	FL	16,894	D+
Safe Ins Co	WV	7,243	D-
San Antonio Indemnity Co	TX	2,725	D+
Select Markets Ins Co	IL	14,078	D
Southern General Ins Co	GA	50,492	D
Southern Mutual Ins Co	GA	12,821	D+
Southern Oak Ins Co	FL	59,594	D
Southland Lloyds Ins Co	TX	3,226	D+
Spring Valley Mutual Ins Co	MN	7,982	E+
St Johns Ins Co Inc	FL	129,016	D
State Farm Florida Ins Co	FL	1,830,575	D
Stonington Ins Co	TX	453,478	D+
Sunshine State Ins Co	FL	47,698	E+
Tower Hill Preferred Ins Co	FL	77,904	D
Tower Hill Prime Ins Co	FL	115,663	D-
Tower Hill Select Ins Co	FL	62,910	D
Tower National Ins Co	MA	54,257	F
Town & Country Mutual Ins Co	AR	2,273	D
U S Lloyds Ins Co	TX	19,618	D
Underwriters At Lloyds	KY	229,164	D+
Underwriters At Lloyds London	IL	663,508	E+
Union Mutual Ins Co	OK	4,044	E+
United Heritage Prop & Cas Co	ID	21,988	D+
United Home Ins Co	AR	11,947	D
Universal Property & Casualty Ins	FL	391,088	E+
Waco Fire & Cas Ins Co	GA	39,824	D
Washington County Co-Operative Ins	NY	6,473	E+
West Virginia Ins Co	WV	38,992	D
West Virginia National Auto Ins Co	WV	9,340	D
Wilmington Ins Co	DE	4,581	D
Wisconsin American Mutual Ins Co	WI	4,015	D
Workmens Auto Ins Co	CA	67,048	D
Zephyr Ins Co Inc	HI	51,421	D-

Weiss Ratings scale: A = excellent, B = good, C = fair, D = weak, E = very weak, F = failed, plus sign = upper third of grade range, minus sign = lower third.

Data source: Statutory financial data reported to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners provided by SNL Financial LC, reflecting data as of December 31, 2009.

Selection criteria: U.S. insurance companies with line-of-business premium of $1 million or more with a Weiss Financial Strength Rating of D+ (Weak) or lower.