Weakest Auto Insurers

Strongest Auto Insurers	Strongest Business Insurers	Strongest Homeowners Insurers
Weakest Auto Insurers	Weakest Business Insurers	Weakest Homeowners Insurers

Company	State	Total Assets ($000)	Weiss Financial Strength Rating
Acceptance Casualty Ins Co	NE	41,170	D+
Access Ins Co	TX	91,035	D+
Accident Ins Co Inc	SC	37,209	E+
Ace Ins Co Of The Midwest	IN	54,515	U
Adirondack Ins Exch	NY	251,543	D
Aequicap Ins Co	FL	38,322	E+
Affirmative Ins Co Of MI	MI	20,550	D
Agent Alliance Ins Co	AL	7,917	D+
Agrinational Ins Co	VT	528,185	E
Alliance Mutual Ins Co	NC	9,898	D+
Alliance Of Nonprofits For Ins Rrg	VT	44,061	D
Alliance United Ins Co	CA	55,505	D
American Contractors Ins Co Risk Ret	TX	17,460	D
American Country Ins Co	IL	93,542	D
American Farmers & Ranchers Ins Co	ID	12,936	D
American Farmers & Ranchers Mutual	OK	85,973	D+
American Fellowship Mut Ins Co	MI	6,704	D
American Forest Casualty Co Rrg	SC	8,567	D-
American Freedom Ins Co	IL	29,296	D+
American Heartland Ins Co	IL	12,993	E+
American Independent Ins Co	PA	79,569	D+
American Manufacturers Mutual Ins Co	IL	11,431	E+
American Millennium Ins Co	NJ	11,275	D
American Motorists Ins Co	IL	20,056	D
American Safety Casualty Ins Co	OK	156,651	D+
American Safety Indemnity Co	OK	231,578	D
American Service Ins Co Inc	IL	179,728	D+
American Sterling Ins Co	CA	18,352	D
American Transit Ins Co	NY	276,154	E+
American Trucking & Transp Ins Rrg	MT	12,964	D-
American Underwriters Ins Co	AR	6,291	D+
American Union Ins Co	IL	61,150	U
Ameriguard Rrg Inc	VT	11,291	D
Apollo Casualty Co	IL	42,685	D+
Apollo Casualty Co Of FL	FL	12,258	D+
Arch Excess & Surplus Ins Co	NE	28,634	U
Argonaut Great Central Ins Co	IL	110,893	D+
Argonaut-Midwest Ins Co	IL	43,502	D+
Ari Casualty Co	NJ	37,168	D+
Arizona Automobile Ins Co	AZ	6,762	D
Assuranceamerica Ins Co	SC	70,315	E
Atlantic Casualty Ins Co	NC	185,667	D+
Atlantic Mutual Ins Co	NY	205,447	E-
Auto Club Casualty Co	TX	2,754	U
Battle Creek Mutual Ins Co	NE	4,746	E
Blue Ridge Ins Co	WI	11,354	U
Bristol West Casualty Ins Co	OH	27,416	D
Bristol West Preferred Ins Co	MI	33,059	D-
Capacity Ins Co	FL	8,543	D
Capitol Ins Co	PA	5,089	D+
Casualty Corp Of America	OK	5,034	E+
Casualty Underwriters Ins Co	UT	4,278	D
Cem Ins Co	IL	9,953	D-
Centennial Ins Co	NY	74,859	E-
Circle Star Ins Co Rrg	VT	1,737	D-
Cities & Villages Mutual Ins Co	WI	38,506	D+
Citizens United Recip Exch	NJ	79,444	D
Coast National Ins Co	CA	588,024	D+
Coastal Ins Rrg Inc	AL	45,255	D-
College Liab Ins Co Ltd Rrg	HI	11,032	D
Colonial Lloyds	TX	28,384	D
Colony National Ins Co	VA	130,460	D+
Colony Specialty Ins Co	OH	112,377	D+
Columbia Federal Ins Co	DC	3,076	D
Commerce Protective Ins Co	PA	6,360	D
Companion Inc	VI	11,211	D
Constitutional Casualty Co	IL	17,768	E+
Consumers County Mutual Ins Co	TX	105,632	D
Countrywide Ins Co	NY	140,506	D-
Crown Captive Ins Co	GA	856	U
Crown Captive Ins Co Inc	DC	3,687	E+
Crum & Forster Indemnity Co	DE	36,062	D+
Delos Ins Co	DE	601,209	D+
Delphi Casualty Co	IL	9,098	D
Discovery Ins Co	NC	30,668	D
Districts Mutual Ins	WI	15,474	E+
Dongbu Ins Co Ltd	HI	36,131	D-
Drivers Ins Co	NY	7,255	D+
Echelon Prop & Cas Ins Co	IL	7,427	E+
Elite Transportation Rrg Inc	AZ	10,595	D
Empire Ins Co	NY	56,739	F
Equitable Liability Ins Co	DC	4,091	D-
Ethio American Ins Co	GA	6,997	E+
Evergreen Usa Rrg Inc	VT	12,770	D+
Executive Ins Co	NY	3,680	U
Explorer Ins Co	CA	196,397	D+
Ez Auto Ins Co	UT	3,746	D+
Fairmont Specialty Ins Co	CA	256,261	D+
Farmers & Mechanics Fire & Cas Ins	WV	4,481	D
Federal Motor Carriers Rrg Inc	DE	24,764	E
Federated National Ins Co	FL	77,398	D-
Fiduciary Ins Co Of America	NY	35,934	D-
First Acceptance Ins Co Inc	TX	207,254	D
First Acceptance Ins Co Of Georgia	GA	60,534	D
First Chicago Ins Co	IL	20,501	D-
First Keystone Rrg Inc	SC	21,882	D
First Net Ins Co	GU	12,805	D-
Fremont Ins Co	MI	89,441	D+
Geneva Ins Co	IN	4,540	D+
Georgia Transportation Captive Ins	GA	1,508	D
Global Hawk Ins Co Rrg	VT	5,914	E
Global Liberty Ins Co Of NY	NY	40,291	D-
Golden Bear Ins Co	CA	97,563	D
Grain Dealers Mutual Ins Co	IN	45,673	D+
Granada Ins Co	FL	26,472	E+
Great Northwest Ins Co	IN	24,658	D
Greenville Casualty Ins Co Inc	SC	10,815	D-
Greenwich Ins Co	DE	927,955	D+
Hallmark Ins Co	AZ	184,834	D
Hallmark Specialty Ins Co	OK	101,386	D+
Harbor Ins Co	OK	11,536	D+
Harbor Specialty Ins Co	NJ	127,380	U
Hereford Ins Co	NY	87,805	D
Home State County Mutual Ins Co	TX	129,258	D
Homeowners Of America Ins Co	TX	13,332	D-
Housing & Redevelopment Ins Exch	PA	38,574	D
Hudson Ins Co	DE	538,664	D
Hudson Specialty Ins Co	NY	212,596	D+
Icm Ins Co	NY	13,860	D
Integrity Prop & Cas Ins Co	WI	13,761	D+
Interboro Mutual Indemnity Ins Co	NY	73,964	E
Interstate Auto Ins Co	MD	5,087	D
Interstate Bankers Casualty Co	IL	20,143	D+
Jamestown Ins Co Rrg	SC	7,706	D-
Kentucky National Ins Co	KY	7,594	D+
Lebanon Mutual Ins Co	PA	26,045	D
Liberty First Rrg Ins Co	UT	3,573	D+
Lincoln General Ins Co	PA	706,433	E+
Lm Property & Casualty Ins Co	IN	93,945	U
Lone Star National Ins Co	IN	3,900	D-
Long Island Ins Co	NY	6,719	E-
Loya Casualty Ins Co	CA	59,309	D-
Loya Ins Co	TX	228,105	D
Lumbermens Mutual Cas Co	IL	1,124,027	E
Maiden Reins Co	MO	639,535	U
Make Transportation Ins Inc Rrg	DE	3,935	E+
Mapfre Insurance Co	NJ	38,137	U
Maxum Casualty Ins Co	DE	12,558	D
Maya Asr Co	NY	10,823	D-
Members Ins Co	NC	6,114	E+
Mercury Indemnity Co Of America	FL	47,123	D-
Mid-Continent Ins Co	PA	40,589	D
Millers First Ins Co	IL	36,857	D+
Missouri Valley Mutual Ins Co	SD	5,593	D+
Montpelier Us Ins Co	OK	67,370	D
Mountain Valley Indemnity Co	NH	72,651	D
Mt Morris Mutual Ins Co	WI	18,674	D+
National American Ins Co Of Ca	CA	38,493	D
National Automotive Ins	LA	18,873	D
National Continental Ins Co	NY	244,107	D+
National Group Ins Co	FL	8,180	D+
National Guaranty Ins Co	AZ	17,676	D-
National Heritage Ins Co	IL	5,451	D+
National Independent Truckers Ic Rrg	SC	7,709	D+
National Interstate Ins Co Of Hawaii	OH	25,665	D
Nevada Direct Ins Co	NV	3,615	D
North East Ins Co	ME	102,408	D
Northern Capital Ins Co	FL	65,238	E
Northwest Gf Mutual Ins Co	SD	10,855	D
Ocean Rrg Inc	DC	15,512	E
Oklahoma Farm Bureau Mutual Ins Co	OK	299,095	D
Oklahoma Property & Cas Ins Co	OK	4,331	E+
Old American Cty Mutual Fire Ins Co	TX	92,978	E+
Ooida Risk Retention Group Inc	VT	57,134	D
Optima Ins Co	PR	40,106	D
Ordinary Mutual A Rrg Corp	VT	50,541	D+
Pacific Indemnity Ins Co	GU	17,895	D+
Pacific Pioneer Insurance Co	CA	22,410	D+
Palisades Ins Co	NJ	26,955	D+
Palisades Property & Casualty Ins	NJ	57,484	D
Paramount Ins Co	MD	7,859	E+
Paratransit Ins Co A Mutual Rrg	TN	21,244	D
Pinelands Ins Co Rrg Inc	DC	8,875	E+
Preferred Auto Ins Co Inc	TN	6,337	D-
Preserver Ins Co	NJ	176,103	D+
Pride National Ins Co	OK	9,529	U
Prime Ins Co	IL	43,794	D
Primero Ins Co	NV	16,331	D-
Princeton Ins Co	NJ	1,022,049	D+
Qbe Specialty Ins Co	ND	343,449	D-
Quality Casualty Ins Co Inc	AL	2,494	E
Reinsurance Co Of America Inc	IL	10,984	D+
Rochdale Ins Co Of New York NY	NY	179,139	D+
Rutgers Casualty Ins Co	NJ	50,952	D+
San Antonio Indemnity Co	TX	2,725	D+
Santa Fe Auto Ins Co	TX	51,011	D+
Security National Ins Co	FL	153,892	D+
Selective Ins Co Of New England	ME	30,762	D
Seminole Casualty Ins Co	FL	46,230	D
Southern Casualty Ins Co	GA	8,823	D
Southern General Ins Co	GA	50,492	D
Southern Mutual Ins Co	GA	12,821	D+
Southland Lloyds Ins Co	TX	3,226	D+
Southwest General Ins Co	NM	3,667	D
Springfield Ins Co Inc	CA	83,718	D
Star Casualty Ins Co	FL	18,650	D
State Farm Guaranty Ins Co	IL	18,601	D+
Sterling Cas Ins Co	CA	21,869	E+
Stonington Ins Co	TX	453,478	D+
Taxisure Exchange	NJ	6,769	D-
Texas Hospital Ins Exchange	TX	29,476	D
Tower National Ins Co	MA	54,257	F
Transit Mutual Ins Corp Of WI	WI	10,802	D
Truststar Ins Co	MD	2,124	D-
Twin Lights Ins Co	NJ	12,166	D
U S Lloyds Ins Co	TX	19,618	D
Underwriters At Lloyds	KY	229,164	D+
Underwriters At Lloyds London	IL	663,508	E+
Union Mutual Ins Co	OK	4,044	E+
Unique Ins Co	IL	38,170	D
United Automobile Ins Co	FL	435,158	E
United Equitable Ins Co	IL	14,969	D
United Group Captive Ins Co	GA	2,206	D
United Heritage Prop & Cas Co	ID	21,988	D+
Unitrin Advantage Ins Co	NY	3,596	D
Universal Casualty Co	IL	130,700	D
Universal Ins Co	NC	25,616	D
Vfh Captive Ins Co	GA	6,432	E+
Victoria National Ins Co	OH	3,379	U
Victoria Specialty Insurance Co	OH	28,128	D
Waco Fire & Cas Ins Co	GA	39,824	D
West Virginia National Auto Ins Co	WV	9,340	D
Wilmington Ins Co	DE	4,581	D
Windhaven Ins Co	FL	9,916	E+
Wisconsin American Mutual Ins Co	WI	4,015	D
Wisconsin Municipal Mutual Ins Co	WI	49,622	D+
Workmens Auto Ins Co	CA	67,048	D
Wrm America Indemnity Co Inc	NY	58,982	U

Weiss Ratings scale: A = excellent, B = good, C = fair, D = weak, E = very weak, F = failed, plus sign = upper third of grade range, minus sign = lower third.

Data source: Statutory financial data reported to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners provided by SNL Financial LC, reflecting data as of December 31, 2009.

Selection criteria: U.S. insurance companies with line-of-business premium of $1 million or more with a Weiss Financial Strength Rating of D+ (Weak) or lower.